Keeping the fingerprint

SUNDAY LETTER · WEEK 42 · 18 OCTOBER 2026

Keeping the fingerprint

Great wines from hard vintages, others losing their own style.

This week was full of tastings, and of preparations for next week's trip. The tastings this week were marked by contrasts. I tasted producers who made fantastic wines in challenging vintages. I also tasted wines that, in my opinion, should not have been made. I know that is a strong view. But when a producer loses their own style, their own fingerprint, is it worth it? Yes, many markets want riper, richer styles than we do up here in the north. But when producers say they prefer the cooler style themselves, they also have to listen to their own words. And they have to find the restraint to hold back. Tuesday was the longest day: twenty-two Champagnes from thirteen producers, from Krug and Dom Pérignon to growers like Georges Laval and Ulysse Collin.

The one to find

Krug Grande Cuvée 174 ÉditionLog in to see the score

"Even in a warm vintage, Krug shows its style, its nerve, its minerality and its own stamp." That was my first line, and it still sums up the wine. It is rich, with clear yellow tones of peach, yellow apple and yellow plum, set under a lovely floral veil. Spice, oak and baked notes build underneath, supporting the richness of the fruit. The finish is mineral, with good acidity giving it backbone.

A flight of Georges Laval

Four cuvées, one clear house style. The Cumières Premier Cru carries the house signature, with minerality, a light flor touch and a rich finish. Garennes shows gunpowder and razor-sharp green apple, with candied citrus and yellow raspberries on the close. Les Chênes 2020 is a real bomb of a wine, yet lean at the same time. Les Hautes Chèvres 2019 is floral and light, with a clear stamp of chalk and a fantastic, buttery finish.

Also worth your attention

Ruinart Dom Ruinart Rosé 2009Log in to see the score

I found clean tones of blood orange, pink grapefruit and candied orange peel. Alongside these, there are oxidised red apple skin and pure wild strawberry. Fine notes of maturity run through it. A baby that will only get better.

Dom Pérignon Rosé 2010Log in to see the score

Fine notes of wild strawberry and rose petals meet the baked character I expect from Dom Pérignon Rosé. There is plenty of minerality here too, leaning towards the saline.

Veuve Fourny & Fils Rosé Vinothèque MV17Log in to see the score

Clear notes of blood orange and grapefruit lead into yellow and red raspberries, with fine red apples. A distinct mineral streak runs through the finish.

The one that didn't quite

Dom Pérignon 2018Log in to see the score

This is a big, rich wine, shaped by a warm vintage. To my mind, it loses much of its minerality and character in the ripe fruit. The concentration and acidity are there, but I expected more from this house in 2018. I hope the true character comes with time.

For the cellar

Ruinart Dom Ruinart Rosé 2009
Krug Grande Cuvée 174 Édition
Georges Laval Les Hautes Chèvres 2019
Ulysse Collin Les Pierrières

The week in numbers

New notes23
Producers13
Magnums1
Top scoreLog in to see the score

The rest of the week

Ulysse Collin

Les MaillonsLog in to see the score

Louis Roederer

Collection 247Log in to see the score
Rosé Vintage 2017Log in to see the score

Moët & Chandon

Collection Impériale Création No. 1Log in to see the score

Ayala

Blanc de Blancs 2019Log in to see the score

Pol Roger

Vintage 2019Log in to see the score

Leclerc Briant

RéserveLog in to see the score
Rosé de SaignéeLog in to see the score

Veuve Fourny & Fils

Monts de Vertus 2017Log in to see the score
Cuvée R Premier CruLog in to see the score

Bollinger

PN AYC21Log in to see the score

Bouché Père & Fils

Blanc de BlancsLog in to see the score
Le Clos le Point du Jour 2014Log in to see the score
→ Read all of this week's notes

Until next Sunday,

Magnus